#!/usr/bin/env python3 """ PR #4319: dynamic pages went out with no Cache-Control at all. Flask does send "Vary: Cookie" on any response that touched the session, so a spec-compliant shared cache would already key these per-session. An edge cache configured to key purely on URL ignores that, and one reporter's Cloudflare Worker did exactly that: it cached /settings, including the csrf_token embedded in the form, and every later save failed with "The CSRF tokens do not match" - or, worse, could hand one session's authenticated page to another visitor. An app-wide after_request fills in Cache-Control when the route didn't set one, so the explicit headers on assets/screenshots/favicons still win. """ import re def test_dynamic_pages_are_not_storable(client, live_server): # Any page carrying session state or a CSRF token - the cached copy is what # breaks form submits and leaks across sessions. for path in ['/', '/settings', '/login']: response = client.get(path) cache_control = response.headers.get('Cache-Control') assert cache_control is not None, ( f"{path} sent no Cache-Control - a URL-keyed edge cache is free to store and " f"replay it, stale CSRF token and all" ) assert 'no-store' in cache_control, ( f"{path} must not be storable by an intermediary, got {cache_control!r}" ) def test_routes_keep_their_own_cache_control(client, live_server): # The hook only fills in a missing header, so routes that deliberately # allow caching must come through untouched. # static_content() sets its own header on assets (see the two tests below), so they # never reach the hook at all. response = client.get('/static/styles/styles.css') assert response.status_code == 200 assert 'no-store' not in response.headers.get('Cache-Control', ''), ( f"static assets should keep werkzeug's own header, got " f"{response.headers.get('Cache-Control')!r}" ) # And a route with an explicit long-lived, publicly cacheable header. response = client.get('/static/flags/4x3/ad.svg') assert response.status_code == 200 assert response.headers.get('Cache-Control') == 'max-age=86400, public', ( f"flag SVGs set their own 24h public cache header, got " f"{response.headers.get('Cache-Control')!r}" ) def test_static_assets_are_cacheable(client, live_server): # Assets used to go out as "no-cache, max-age=0", so every CSS/JS/image on every page # load cost a request (a 304, but still a round trip). url_for() now fingerprints the # URL with the file's mtime+size, and a matching ?v= is what buys the long cache. res = client.get('/') assert res.status_code == 200 versioned = re.findall(r'(/static/(?:js|styles|images|favicons)/[^"?]+\?v=[0-9-]+)', res.data.decode()) assert versioned, "no fingerprinted asset URLs in the rendered page - ?v= is what unlocks caching" for url in set(versioned): response = client.get(url) assert response.status_code == 200, url assert response.headers.get('Cache-Control') == 'public, max-age=31536000, immutable', ( f"{url} is pinned to one file revision so it should be cacheable forever, got " f"{response.headers.get('Cache-Control')!r}" ) # The session cookie is permanent and re-signed on every response, so its value keeps # changing - a "Vary: Cookie" here would miss the cache on every asset of every page load. assert 'cookie' not in response.headers.get('Vary', '').lower(), ( f"{url} must not vary by cookie, got {response.headers.get('Vary')!r}" ) assert 'Set-Cookie' not in response.headers, ( f"{url} is publicly cacheable, it must not carry a session cookie" ) assert response.headers.get('ETag'), f"{url} sent no ETag" def test_unversioned_static_assets_still_revalidate(client, live_server): # Older cached HTML (or a hand-typed URL) has no ?v=, and a stale one must not be trusted # either - both have to keep revalidating so an upgrade can't serve the wrong file forever. for url in ['/static/js/toggle-theme.js', '/static/js/toggle-theme.js?v=1-1']: response = client.get(url) assert response.status_code == 200, url assert response.headers.get('Cache-Control') == 'public, max-age=0, must-revalidate', ( f"{url} isn't pinned to a known file revision so it must be revalidated, got " f"{response.headers.get('Cache-Control')!r}" ) etag = response.headers.get('ETag') assert etag, f"{url} sent no ETag - revalidation would re-download the whole file" # ETag is werkzeug's own mtime-size-path token, so revalidation is a cheap 304. assert client.get(url, headers={'If-None-Match': etag}).status_code == 304