mirror of
https://github.com/dgtlmoon/changedetection.io.git
synced 2026-09-18 19:36:04 +00:00
dgtlmoonandClaude Opus 5
8d938b5966
* Browser fetchers - Judge a fetch on the document we end up extracting, not the first navigation
The goal is to compare the text of the page the browser lands on, even when the site navigates
again after the first response. Both fetchers were bound to the first navigation, which shows up
as two different bugs:
1. pyppeteer hangs until the hard processing timeout. Its navigation watcher is bound to the
loaderId of the navigation it started, so when the site replaces that document the 'load' it
waits for never arrives for that loaderId. With timeout=0 and setDefaultNavigationTimeout(0)
there is nothing to break the wait, so goto() blocks until
PUPPETEER_MAX_PROCESSING_TIMEOUT_SECONDS (180s) kills the fetch and the watch records an empty
xpath_data - while the browser is sitting on a fully loaded page. Traced on slated.com:
0.24s goto start
0.74s main frame networkIdle loaderId=A0E0E0B2 <- never gets 'load'
2.72s main frame init loaderId=56D2B5EF <- re-navigated to get.slated.com
3.49s main frame load loaderId=56D2B5EF <- fires for the new document
25.2s goto still hanging, frame._loaderId is now 56D2B5EF
Now the navigation races goto() against the main frame firing 'load', bounded by
BROWSER_NAVIGATION_TIMEOUT_SECONDS (default 30), and falls back to the document we can see.
slated.com / getastra.com / addupsolutions.com went from a 180s timeout with no content to
200 with full content in 5-35s.
2. Both fetchers reported the status of the interstitial. A site that gates unseen visitors with
an error status plus a client-side redirect (reported against fotokoch.de: 503 + meta refresh,
then a 200 with the real page) failed the watch even though the content was present, and the
only workaround was ignore_status_codes, which also hides genuine 404s and 500s forever.
The fetchers now keep the latest main-frame document response and judge on that - the refresh
lands during the existing extra_wait, so the 200 wins.
Playwright also waits for a settled load state before extracting, which is what produced
"Execution context was destroyed, most likely because of a navigation" when the refresh collided
with extraction.
The navigation-response tracker is installed once per page and shared between the fetcher and
action_goto_url() rather than each navigation adding its own listener - 'response' fires once per
HTTP response, hundreds of times on a heavy page, so the callbacks are worth not duplicating.
Verified one listener remains after an install plus four navigations.
Selenium is unaffected either way - it hardcodes status_code = 200 because WebDriver cannot see
the HTTP status.
Tested: new test_renavigation.py covers the interstitial case end to end and was checked to fail
without the fix and pass with it, on both fetchers. The test endpoint gates on last-seen time
rather than a hit count, because a counter lets the second check see a clean 200 and the test
then passes without the fix. Full browser suite 11 passed on playwright and on pyppeteer, 494
unit tests pass.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* Puppeteer fetcher - One content-ready deadline instead of a stopLoading watchdog per frame event
Page.stopLoading is what stops a page that would otherwise load forever waiting on a subresource
that never answers, so that we can still screenshot and scrape what rendered. That intent was
right, but it was implemented as a fire-and-forget task armed by every frame event, which measured
on a single fetch of an iframe-heavy page came to:
14 watchdog tasks spawned
11 page-wide Page.stopLoading calls
3 tasks outliving the fetch and firing against a closed page
Page.stopLoading takes no frame or loader argument - it is the Stop button, and it stops the whole
page. Verified directly: one call stopped a pending main frame and a pending iframe in the same
instant. So the other 10 calls were redundant, and because they landed at arbitrary later times
they could stop a *subsequent* navigation we actually wanted - which is the likeliest reason the
same URL fetched in 8s on one run and 35s on the next.
Replaced with a single deadline, awaited inline so nothing can outlive the fetch (there is no
create_task left in this file at all):
navigate (bounded) -> wait the configured delay -> Page.stopLoading -> extract
The delay is measured from when navigation finished, not from when it started. Anchoring it to the
start would quietly rob a slow-loading page of its settle time, and letting JS-rendered content
appear after load is the whole point of the setting. Verified with a server that takes 5s to answer
and renders via JS 2s after load: total 9.6s for a 4s delay, and the late content is captured.
Because a page is never reliably "finished" - many sites navigate as part of their normal design -
the delay restarts when the MAIN frame replaces its document, so a redirect or interstitial gets
the same settle time the first document got. Iframes do not restart it, and it is capped by
BROWSER_CONTENT_READY_MAX_RESETS (default 2).
Only the existing "wait n seconds before extracting text" stays user-facing;
BROWSER_NAVIGATION_TIMEOUT_SECONDS is a safety net with a sane default rather than a second knob
for users to reason about. This matches what other scrapers do: bound the navigation, do not fail
when it times out, settle, then extract.
Timings are also more predictable now - the four reported URLs went from 5-35s of variance to
4.6-7.2s at a 3s delay, all with full content and a 200.
Tested: 11 passed pyppeteer browser suite, 7 passed playwright, 494 unit + llm.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>